When Do I Admit That My Original Business Model Isn’t Working?
When to pivot and when to stay the course.
When we started The Advisory Bench, we thought a technology platform would be an important part of our offering. The idea was to give CEOs a place to manage their interactions with Advisors and make the process easier.
It sounded useful to us. Our customers had a different opinion.
We found out quickly that CEOs didn't want another software platform. They already had email and Slack and Outlook and Google and Zoom… they certainly didn't need another login and another password.
What they wanted was the right people: Advisors who had dealt with the issues they were facing. They didn't care much about the software that was supposed to connect them.
Once we understood that, the answer was clear. We needed to concentrate on finding the right Advisors, not convincing customers they should use a tool they hadn't asked for.
We also saw that customers were coming to us through relationships, particularly through my network. Instead of insisting that our original approach was how the business should work, we had to pay attention to what was actually happening.
This is a common problem for founders. You start a company because you have an idea about what customers need. You put time and money behind it. You make plans, build things and get attached to the way you believe the business should operate.
Then customers tell you something different.
The trick is knowing when to listen and change course, and when to stick with a strategy that's simply taking time to develop. Building a company is hard. You don't want to abandon a good idea just because the early going is difficult.
But you also don't want to spend two years trying to convince customers they need something they clearly don't value.
To help sort that out, ask yourself:
- What topics are generating customer interest in our conversations? When we talked about software, we got a snoozefest. When we talked about people with expertise, customers engaged.
- What solutions are customers using today for what you could offer, and what are the pain points with those solutions?
- What do our current customers like about the product or service we are providing, and what do they dislike?
- What is our core strength as a company, and does our business model rotate around that? In our case, we weren’t software experts. We were connectors.
Here's how I would approach it:
From my experience, here's what I'd suggest:
1. Conduct a 10-customer reality check.
Interview ten current customers, lost prospects, or potential customers. Ask each the same five questions about the problem they're trying to solve, how they solve it today, what frustrates them, what they value most about your offering, and what they'd actually pay for. Don't pitch your solution during these conversations. Look for patterns in the answers. If eight out of ten tell you the same thing, pay attention.
2. Track what customers actually buy, not what they say they like.
Review your last 20 sales conversations or opportunities. Create a simple spreadsheet with three columns: What we offered, what generated interest, and what the customer ultimately purchased (or why they declined). Look for disconnects. At The Advisory Bench, the software sounded interesting in theory, but access to experienced Advisors was what generated genuine interest. Customer behavior is more reliable than compliments.
3. Run a 30-day test of an alternative approach.
Before abandoning your original model, test the alternative on a small scale. For example, offer two versions of your service to comparable prospects—one emphasizing your original approach and one emphasizing what customers seem to want instead. Track qualified conversations, proposals, and actual purchases. You don't need a perfect experiment, but you do need evidence that the alternative works better before making a major change.
4. Put your business model through a strengths test.
Write down the three capabilities your company does exceptionally well, the three things customers value most, and the three activities that generate the most revenue or profit. Look for the overlap. That's where your business model should probably concentrate. At The Advisory Bench, the overlap was connecting CEOs with experienced people—not building software.
Chris's Lesson: Listen to What Your Customers Are Buying
With The Advisory Bench, our mission didn't change. We still wanted to help CEOs close their experience gap with the benefit of Advisors who had been through the challenges they were facing.
What changed was our understanding of how customers wanted to get that help.
We thought they would value a platform. But they had platforms. What they were struggling with was finding hard-to-find talent. Once that became obvious, it made no sense to keep pushing the software.
My advice is to be stubborn about solving the customer's problem, but not about the particular solution you came up with first.
If customers are consistently telling you that something else matters more, listen.
I'd be happy to chat with you about it. Let's Start a Conversation.